“What’s Sex Got to do With…Hip-Hop Queens?”

beyonce_ifiwere6

tumblr_static_ciara-like-a-boy

Music. We dance to it, we sing along to it, we learn from it. As we have seen time and time again, music is a medium that provides insight to our culture. Good music is relatable, it evokes some sort of emotion, and it engages the listener in its message. Artists can reach huge audiences with their music, placing them in highly influential positions.

While learning about gender roles, sexual subjectivity, and heteronormative culture, I realized that I’ve heard these topics being discussed in popular music but haven’t taken much notice of them before. Two artists in particular have written songs specifically about gender roles and behaviors in relationships, essentially demonstrating how male and female sexuality are characterized in our society. Ciara’s “Like a Boy” and Beyoncé’s “If I Were a Boy” depict stereotypical behaviors of men and women in heterosexual relationships. These women are highlighting the double standards and behaviors that society has constructed to be normative of these relationships. Let’s first take a look at Ciara’s song “Like a Boy”:

 

 [Verse: 1]

Pull up your pants

(Just Like Em’)

Take out the trash

(Just Like Em’)

getting ya cash like em’

Fast like em’

Girl you outta act like ya dig

(What I’m talkin’ bout’)

Security codes on everything

Vibrate so your phone don’t ever ring

(Joint Account)

And another one he don’t know about

 [Hook]

Wish we could switch up the roles

And I could be that…

Tell you I love you

But when you call I never get back

Would you ask them questions like me?…

Like where you be at?

Cause I’m out 4 in the morning

On the corner rolling

Doing my own thing

Oh

 [Chorus:]

What if I?…

Had a thing on the side?

Made ya cry?

Would the rules change up?…

Or would they still apply?…

If I played you like a toy?…

Sometimes I wish I could act like a boy

 …

She begins with male behaviors, reinforced by the line “Just like ‘em,” and begins to mention behaviors that men undertake that ultimately display women as being dependent on the male figure. Consequentially, the men hold power over the women because their actions dictate how the woman feels and reacts. It is evident that she is really trying to convey a message about the injustice of gender roles. She isn’t playfully suggesting that males and females should swap places for a while; she is drawing attention to the imbalance of gender roles in relationships. In the hook, Ciara says, “Tell you I love you, but when you call I never get back.” And in the chorus she has a line that says, “Would the rules change up? Or would they still apply? If I played you like a toy? Sometimes I wish I could act like a boy.” Are women simply objects to be used at the disposal of men, like “toys,” to satisfy their sexual desires? This is an idea confronted in Tolman’s article “Adolescent Girl’s Sexuality.” Obviously it is apparent enough so that a huge hip-hop artist such as Ciara dedicated an entire song to it. What would happen if the females were in positions of control, how would men react? Why must men always have the upper hand or treat girls as though they are disposable? These ideas are also found in Beyoncé’s popular anthem “If I were a Boy.” Her song is very similar to Ciara’s in that she calls out male behaviors but further, she demonstrates how dependent women are on the behavior of the man. Here is Queen B’s “If I were a Boy”:

 

 

 

 

[Verse]

If I were a boy

Even just for a day

I’d roll outta bed in the morning

And throw on what I wanted and go

Drink beer with the guys

And chase after girls

I’d kick it with who I wanted

And I’d never get confronted for it.

‘Cause they’d stick up for me.

 [Chorus]

If I were a boy

I think I could understand

How it feels to love a girl

I swear I’d be a better man.

I’d listen to her

‘Cause I know how it hurts

When you lose the one you wanted

‘Cause he’s taken you for granted

And everything you had got destroyed

 [Verse]

If I were a boy

I would turn off my phone

Tell everyone it’s broken

So they’d think that I was sleepin’ alone

I’d put myself first

And make the rules as I go

‘Cause I know that she’d be faithful

Waitin’ for me to come home (to come home)

 

 In their songs, these two artists are speaking out against the stereotypical behavior of men that puts females in positions of lesser power in relationships. The question remains though, why have women been allowing themselves to be the subjects of male sexuality? Society has constructed all of these binaries, has regulated normality and specified gender appropriate behaviors in such ways that have characterized women as being inferior to men. Perhaps by explicitly re-creating some of these behaviors in their songs, Beyoncé and Ciara have been able to point out the ways in which women have ultimately allowed said behavior to continue.   As women are becoming more in touch with themselves as sexual beings and advocate for gender equality, will such gender roles in relationships continue as they are?

 

 

One thought on ““What’s Sex Got to do With…Hip-Hop Queens?”

  1. for both ciara and Beyonce i love both of their music and what they stand for. i think both are good role models to kids in this world. i think both videos express a lot of what other females wanted to say about men treating women. i think the songs send off a good message and let men think about what if. i love this post and like the way that it was thought through

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s